Book a Consult

Protecting Children’s Best Interests in a Custody Battle

  • | Category: Child Law

Custody disputes are often the most difficult part of a divorce. In this case, the wellbeing of two young children was at stake, with both parents fighting for primary care. The challenge was to find a solution that gave the children stability while protecting their relationships with both parents.

Client Background (Anonymised)

“Sarah” and “David” were going through a divorce. Their children, Emma (11) and Josh (8), became the focus of a contested custody dispute. Sarah believed David was too emotionally distant, while David felt Sarah’s demanding travel schedule created instability for the children.

Legal Strategy & Approach

To move past the conflict, we worked with the opposing attorneys to appoint a forensic psychologist who specialises in child custody matters. The expert:

  • Interviewed both parents and the children.
  • Spoke to teachers and caregivers.
  • Assessed what would provide the children with the most stable and nurturing environment.

The assessment found that both parents were loving and capable. However, the children needed a predictable routine, which David could provide more consistently. We crafted a parenting plan to protect the children’s bond with both parents:

  • Primary residence with David.
  • Alternate weekends with Sarah, from Thursday to Monday morning.
  • An additional midweek overnight stay with Sarah.

Outcome & Impact

The court adopted this arrangement, confirming it was in the children’s best interests. The outcome provided:

  • Stability and routine with their father as the resident parent.
  • Frequent and meaningful contact with their mother.
  • Clear recognition that both parents hold equal rights and responsibilities, with the focus placed on the children’s needs rather than gender roles.

Conclusion & Key Takeaways

This case shows how the right legal strategy and expert input can turn a bitter custody fight into a balanced, child-centred solution. Most importantly, it highlights that South African law always prioritises what is best for the children, ensuring they have the love and stability they deserve from both parents.